1926

1928 1930 1931 1934 1942 1943 1944 1946 1964 1967 1968 1982 1985 1987 2004 2006

World Championship Seasons | National League Pennant Seasons


 

  Click to go "home"

C O N T E N T S

     Championships

     By The Numbers

     Honors and Awards

     Confines

     Other


     Post Season Summary

      


 

 

This site is dedicated to the memory of my Dad, Robert H. "Bob" Knell, Sr., the greatest Cardinal fan ever!!!

 

 

 

The Best and the Worst

Best Season | Worst Season | Best Player | Best Pitcher | Best Reliever | Best Defensive Player | Best Trades | Worst Trades | Best-looking Players | Ugliest Players | Best Nicknames | Most Unappreciated Player | Most Overrated Player | Most Admirable Stars | Least Admirable Stars | Best Season - Hitter | Best Season - Pitcher | Most Impressive Individual Record | Fan Favorites


Best Season
1946 - The Cardinals and Dodgers finished in a dead heat.  In a 3-game playoff, the Cardinals won the first two games to advance to the World Series.  The Fall Classic went down to the late innings of Game 7 before Enos Slaughter's "mad dash" home secured the championship for St. Louis
  
Worst Season
1897 - The club went 29-102, finished 23.5 games behind the next-worst club in the National League, and didn't win a single series all year.  The team went through FOUR managers before owner Chris von der Ahe took the reins.  Contemporary publications rated their performance "the worst in history."
  
Best Player
Stan Musial - Rogers Hornsby might have been better at his peak, but Musial was productive for a much longer period and he didn't get himself traded out of town.
  
Best Pitcher
Bob Gibson - All he did is throw 13 shutouts in 1968 on his way to a 1.12 Earned Run Average and 22 victories in 34 games.  He is the Cardinals leader in most pitching categories, including wins (251), losses (174), games started (482), complete games (255), and shutouts (56).  He threw his only no-hitter on August 14, 1971 against the Pittsburgh Pirates.
  
Best Reliever
Bruce Sutter - He saved 102 games in a three-season span, including 36 during the 1982 Championship Season.  He is third on the all-time saves list with 127 and 20th on the all-time games appeared list with 249.
  
Best Defensive Player
Ozzie Smith - He set the standard with his artistry at shortstop, including 11-straight Gold Glove awards from 1982 to 1992..  Other St. Louis defensive greats include Terry Moore, Ken Boyer, Bill White, Bob Gibson, Curt Flood, Keith Hernandez and Terry Pendleton.
  
Best Trades
Curt Flood, Lou Brock, Willie McGee, Joaquin Andujar, John Tudor and George Hendrick - Flood was acquired from the Reds in the winter of '57 in a five-player deal that cost the Cardinals little more than reliever Willard Schmidt.  Seven years later, Brock was added to the outfield via a six-player deal that sent over-the-hill hurler Ernie Broglio to the Cubs.  In 1981, the Cardinals stole minor league outfielder Willie McGee from the Yankees for washed-up southpaw Bob Sykes, and nabbed Andujar in a midsummer deal that sent outfield Tony Scott to Houston.  In 1985, the Cardinals captured the NL pennant on the strength of the arms of Andujar and Tudor.  The latter came over from Pittsburgh in a 1984 trade for outfielder Hendrick.  Hendrick had given the Cardinals seven good years after the Padres traded him to St. Louis for pitcher Eric Rasmussen in 1978.
  
Worst Trades
Three Fingers Brown, Paul Derringer, and Steve Carlton - few teams have given away three finer arms.  After going 9-13 as a rookie in 1903, Brown was dealt to the Cubs in a disastrous four-player swap.  Derringer was lost to the Reds in a 1933 deal that netted shortstop Leo Durocher and little else.  Finally, Carlton was traded straight-up for Rick Wise in 1972.  In their post-Cardinals careers, Brown, Derringer, and Carlton won 230, 194 and 252 games, respectively.  By comparison, the only two pitchers who've won more than 163 games for the Cardinals are Bob Gibson (251) and Jesse Haines (210).
  
Best Looking Players
Allen Sothoron, Joe Magrane, Bob Gibson, Bill White
  
Ugliest Players
Branch Rickey, Slim Sallee, Fred Beebe, Willie McGee
  
Best Nicknames
Harry "The Cat" Brecheen; Harvey "Kitten" Haddix; "The Big Cat" Johnny Mize; Jim "Kitty" Kaat; "Bad News" Galloway; "Pink" Hawley; John "Soldier Boy" Murphy; "Dots" Miller; "Dizzy" Dean; "Peanuts" Lowrey; "Vinegar Bend" Mizell; "Rebel" Oates; "Cotton" Pippen; "Creepy" Crespi; Joe "Ducky" Medwick
  
Most Unappreciated Player
First baseman Ed Konetchy was one of the Senior Circuit's premier run producers for five years before being dealt to Pittsburgh following the 1913 season.  Center fielder Terry Moore was well-respected in his day, but has been largely forgotten.
  
Most Overrated Player
Vince Coleman - Great base-stealer, awful ballplayer
  
Most Admirable Stars
Stan Musial, Ozzie Smith
  
Least Admirable Stars
Rogers Hornsby, Garry Templeton
  
Best Season - Hitter
Rogers Hornsby 1922 - Hornsby won the Triple Crown by the widest margin in history.  He batted .401; 47 points higher than anyone in the NL.  He hit 42 homeruns; nobody else in the NL hit more than 26.  He drove in 154 runs, 20 more than the closest competitor.
 
Best Season - Pitcher
Bob Gibson - 1968 - Even in "the year of the pitcher," Gibson's 1.12 ERA was 63 percent lower than the league ERA.  Since the advent of the lively ball, no other pitcher has bested the league's ERA by more than 57 percent.  Although his won-loss record was "only" 22-9, three of those losses were by the score of 1-0.  By the same token, he won four 1-0 games that year.  When the Cardinals scored three runs or more for him, he went 13-1.  When they gave him one or two runs, he went 8-5.  From June 6 through July 30, he made 11 starts and went 11-0, with an ERA of 0.27.
   
Most Impressive Individual Record
Bob Gibson's NL-record seven World Series Victories - In nine World Series starts, he went 7-1 with a 1.89 ERA and won Game 7 in both the 1964 and 1967 World Series.  He might have won Game 7 in 1968 if Curt Flood hadn't misjudged a fly ball.
 
Fan Favorites
Dizzy Dean, Stan Musial, Ozzie Smith, Willie McGee

 

The Best and the Worst page has had Hit Counter visitors.

 
 

© Entire contents copyright 2000, 2001-2006 by Kevin Knell.  All rights reserved.  Any previously copyrighted material is property of the respective owner, and its use herein does not represent any relationship between parties.  Site originally posted 21 August, 2000.